Tuesday, October 22, 2013

What a dog and monkey taught me about management at Google

What a Dog and a Monkey Taught Me About Management at Google

What a Dog and a Monkey Taught Me About Management at Google





At all hands meetings on Tuesday afternoons, our 75 person AdSense Ops team reviewed the most important metrics for the business: Top-two box customer satisfaction scores, revenue growth and customer churn.
But unlike every other all hands meeting I attended, these meetings ended with a monkey and a dog. Our director, Kim Malone, would stand up and call for two stuffed animals, first, Whoops the Monkey and Second, Duke the Dog, both of whom employees had carried to the meeting.
At the mention of Whoops, a handful of team members would stand up and one-by-one retell the story of a mistake, big or small. It might have been a mishandled customer case, a forgotten internal data analysis or causing a car accident on the way to work. Often, the team's managers and directors contributed anecdotes. Once or twice, an employee's Whoops mistake cost Google millions of dollars. After hearing all the yarns, the team voted on the worst mistake and Whoops would be thrown from one side of the room to the other, finding the "winner" of the competition who would put the monkey in his or her cubicle for the week.
Then Duke the dog was summoned. In contrast to Whoops' self-reported monkeywrench mistakes, Duke stories are retold by someone else and the dog is a reward for service to the team that went above and beyond the call of duty. Several Googlers would stand and tell a story of a teammate's dedication: how a colleague alerted them of a problem in a customer's account, or stayed late that week to process unusually high customer spoort volumes, or released an internal tool that might have increased our productivity dramatically. Again, the team would vote on the stories and Duke would be bestowed on the winner. Then, the all hands meeting adjourned.
Despite their childlike simplicity, Duke and Whoops, were incredibly effective management tools. Whoops created a culture of honesty and transparency, where mistakes were shared in an environment of openness, trust and support. With Whoops, Kim created a culture that valued learning and camraderie over pride.
Duke celebrated our internal successes. Each week, we wanted to win Duke because we knew whatever effort we contributed at the very least would be celebrated before our teammates and Duke, prominently displayed on in our cubicle would remind our teammates and start conversations. That knowledge made us all work harder.
To the individual, it mattered who won Duke and Whoops. But sharing all of the stories, building a community based on shared experience and trust, was far more important and beneficial to the team. The dog and the monkey were tools to weave a fabric of shared experience and create a culture of strong values.
The first time I interviewed at Google, Kim told me about a book she was writing. A little more than 8 years later, Kim has finally published that book. This week, I'd like to nominate Kim for Duke because of her perseverance and her commitment to achieving her dream.




Alan Russell



  • Flag and HideMargaret Poswistilo
    Margaret Poswistilo
    Vice President of Operations,Human Resources at Next Opportunity Group
    We used similar practices in the 90's in the hotel industry. Eventually, our teams voted to discontinue the Whoops award as they found it to be embarrassing and negative. We still continued to discuss mistakes, but no negative award was given to team members for errors t. We kept the Duke type awards and everyone fared much better.
    22 hours ago
    3 Replies
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
    • Flag and HideRobert H
      Robert H 2nd
      Project Manager at Sony Computer Entertainment America LLC
      A large part of that would be based on how the culture within the organization viewed the "award". If the person was allowed to be ridiculed or set as an example of "what not to do", then I can see the eventual decay of the team from it. But this leads to the other aspect that some of the responses seem to gloss over. These tools, are just that, tools. It still falls to the management team to ensure these tools are used appropriately and not allowed to be corrupted into a negative situation. Communication of the idea that the award is not meant to be a punishment, simply a reminder that we can all improve on our day to day tasks. I'm interested to know if you ever had behavior/performance or attitude issues from people who won the Duke award more than once (or even consistently).
      14 hours ago
    • Flag and HideTodd Presley, SPHR
      Todd Presley, SPHR
      Exec. Director of Human Resources
      I wondered about that, too. I like the idea of transparency but the week-long public shaming seems antithetical to the entire project.
      15 hours ago
    • Show More
  • Flag and HidePramod Kumar Srivastava
    Pramod Kumar Srivastava
    Consultant-CEO, Corporate Performance Improvement Consultant, Trusted Advisor, Truth Seeker & Global Citizen
    Superb!! Alas, we all had such practices all around us. Our world would soon become a haven. Blessed are the People who can talk from their heart, without fear and favor.
    22 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideJay McLeod
    Jay McLeod
    Project Manager - Finance at Ford Motor Company
    It is unfortunate that acceptance of mistakes isn't pervasive across all companies. Some have an entrenched "blame" culture, where being the person with the hot potato gets you more than a few inappropriate 4-letter words from V.P.'s, and people making more effort to cover up mistakes than learning from them.
    21 hours ago
    1 Reply
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HidePaula Day
    Paula Day
    Organizational Change Specialist | Executive Coach | Talent Management | L&D Strategy | Facilitator
    Tomasz, thanks for sharing and reminding us that in a world full of management best practice books & theories, a simple process of (blame free) sharing and anchoring can create great engagement. performance and teamwork. I agree with Margaret & Todd that having a Whoops on display for a week is not the best way to reinforce positivity, having Whoops in the room during story telling though is a good way to lighten the mood when sharing a difficult mistake. I worked at an organisation where mistakes were accepted, leaned from and moved on from,. I also worked at a place where as Jay has highlighted below there is a blame culture of who's accountable which makes people hide from sharing and learning. The former was the best place I've worked, the latter was not a good environment and is a culture I now avoid. Unfortunately it seems that in the rush to grow globally, many companies are not prepared to accept that mistakes are a natural part of growth and that its good to learn from them collaboratively. My concern is the fear/blame culture is becoming more prevalent - is that what others see?
    7 hours ago
    1 Reply
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
    • Flag and HideSunil Talati
      Sunil Talati
      Technical Support Manager
      There is also the cultural part that we have to understand. I have worked with many different cultures and some would not be open to such transparency. However change is possible and any person in leadership position can be a catalyst for change. Fear and Blame are elements but also lack of empowerment, true empowerment which means trusting your colleagues with your hard earned cash. I agree with you that those environments which are not open to sharing and learning from mistakes are not a good environment.
      7 hours ago
      vijay Desai and Paula Day
  • Flag and HideRichard Cross
    Richard Cross
    Account Manager
    Such a simple, but great idea. All too often staff feel they have to be perfect, non mistake making robots and end up burying small mistakes that turn into big ones later down the line.
    21 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideMike McGannon
    Mike McGannon
    Business Analyst & Project Manager
    Sounds like the new Dilbert to me, a Dog and a Monkey..............
    21 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideJesse Kaellis
    Jesse Kaellis
    Published author at Mountain Springs House
    Reading about corporate culture makes me feel better about being such a loser.
    12 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideLisa Remsa
    Lisa Remsa
    Sales Agent Manager at Pioneer Telephone Inc.
    This is an amazing team-building activity and I'm sure helps maintain great morale.
    21 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideT Ravi chandran
    T Ravi chandran
    Manager P&CS at Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited
    Accepting others mistakes and honouring others achievements ! Great motivational tools. It will create great teams.
    21 hours ago
    PIYUSH PATEL
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideDavid Pearce
    David Pearce
    MSc MBA Dip.M FCIM - ICT/TMT Marketing, Business & Corporate Development Professional
    I have to agree with Ms Poswistilo, positive performance should be recognised but 'marking out' people for making mistakes or poor performance should be avoided. Yes, an open atmosphere where people are encouraged to discuss where things went wrong and learn from these mistakes is to be encouraged (normal Keizen practice), but marking out individals in any way is desctructive to team spirit and performance, especially in 'high ego' teams.
    4 hours ago
    Justin McConkey
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideArden Henderson
    Arden Henderson
    Account Manager at AT&T
    This is an innovative way of promoting accountablility and collaboration. I will definintely share this with my leadership.
    21 hours ago
    Manoj K.
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideJennifer Turner, PHR
    Jennifer Turner, PHR
    HR Generalist & Office Manager at Marsh McLennan Agency,LLC
    I love this story!!!
    21 hours ago
    Manoj K.
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideShawn S Coffee
    Shawn S Coffee
    Process Engineer at Tronics Mems
    In my line of work, customers tend to be unhappy due to high amounts of pressure to succeed and unrealistic expectations. Apologizing is just part of the game. This quick game seems an excellent way to bring out employees' errors without being destructive in the same manner. Team building is also accomplished. Very impressive.
    21 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideMarla Cukor
    Marla Cukor
    Public Relations Manager at Creative Marketing Alliance
    Thanks for sharing this great article. From reading the comments and responses to your story, I think one of the important takeaways is that promoting a culture where people feel the freedom to occasionally fail while they are busy striving to succeed -- and along the way, encouraging them to "give props to" the efforts of their co-workers at the same time, leads to creating a business culture where progress and creativity can flourish and grow. Ironically, we have an actually "dog-friendly" office here at CMA, (a full-service marketing and advertising firm based in Central NJ) , so there are always a lot of real "dogs' in our building -- there is even an occasion real "whoops," moment, too! Thanks for the great story.- Marla Cukor
    21 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HidePhilip Fisher
    Philip Fisher
    Experienced Team Lead.
    Great anecdote and definitely a great way of sharing news among the team without a feeling of finger pointing. It should always be about the team as a whole. We win and sometimes lose together but whatever the result you always have the lessons learned and come back stronger. Nicely worded Tomasz. Looks like Duke should be heading your way for spreading the good news and sharing best practices.
    22 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideMike Wikan
    Mike Wikan
    Design Director at E-Line Media/Austin
    We did something similar back at Accolade Software in the Antediluvian era, except our "Whoops!" was "The Brain" which was a Nerf-Brain-Football which went to the poor stalwart for the week. Sadly, there was no corresponding "Duke the Dog" which may explain why there is no more Accolade.
    22 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideAudrey Martins
    Audrey Martins
    Looking for a job in an International company.
    What an amazing way to support team-work and allow communication !! It might seem childlike and simple at first however it is such an effective and creative way to congratulate individuals on their hard work while praising the group and ensuring communication in a honest, transparent and open space ! Bravo for finding a simple & effective tactic resting on trust - camaraderie and student mentality are indeed prevailing over pride ! Thank you for sharing this example, i will keep it in mind as an innovative way to ensure team-work !
    22 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideNick Thompson
    Nick Thompson
    Sales and Marketing Manager at Delve Partners, LLC
    Nice article...the ability to communicate as a team about successes and failures is one of the hallmarks of any great company www.delvepartners.com www.getdelve.com
    21 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideElesia Forgie
    Elesia Forgie
    Student at City University of New York-Brooklyn College
    This is a very creative and innovative way to build rapport amongst colleagues. great management strategy!
    21 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Flag and HideGeoffrey Cestaro
    Geoffrey Cestaro
    Senior Development Officer for Systems (aka MIS Manager) at The Metropolitan Museum of Art
    I kind of thought this was mgmt 101. But now they're doing it at Google!
    21 hours ago
    Alan Russell
    
    
    
    
  • Show More
Delete Flag and Hide
Delete
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

No comments:

Post a Comment